Talk:Assassination Attempt on Caspian X


 * Wasn't the point of this occurence more to summon up the White Witch, rather than to kill Caspian? I mean the article itself specifies that the attempt on Caspian's life was not premeditated, so surely cannot be counted as an assassination attempt? I suggest that this article be replaced with an account of Miraz's attempt on Caspian's life, which would have been an assassination. Poggin 20:43, 27 December 2008 (UTC)
 * I agree. What name should we move it to?
 * Yeah, this event described in this article is Nikabrick's attempt to conjure up the White Witch to fight the Telmarines. The attempted assassination of Caspian would be when Miraz tried to kill him after his son was born.  This article shouldn't be moved, it should be rewritten so that it discusses the proper event that it is referring to.  The info in this article now is already covered on the Jadis page.  Besides, you can't have a spur of the moment assassination, that doesn't make any sense.  16:19, 16 August 2009 (UTC)

Automated transfer of Problem Report #16760
The following message was left by Poggin via PR #16760 on 2008-12-28 01:44:23 UTC

Wasn't the point of this occurence more to summon up the White Witch, rather than to kill Caspian? I mean the article itself specifies that the attempt on Caspian's life was not premeditated, so surely cannot be counted as an assassination attempt? I suggest that this article be replaced with an account of Miraz's attempt on Caspian's life, which was an assassination attempt.