Talk:Gorilla

This page seems fairly irrelevant to the books, which never mention gorillas; all the information is either movie-based or about gorillas in our world. I suggest we remove the stats about gorillas' sizes and other scientific info (as they are in no way relevant to Narnia, either book or film), and add a movie-based notice at the top. Since that would essentially be removing half the page, I wanted some confirmation before I actually execute. Thoughts? Lasaraleen Tarkheena (talk) 18:48, August 19, 2012 (UTC)


 * I agree with putting the movie logo on it, as I just plain forgot that. But I disagree with removing all the scientific info. I mean, Lewis based most of the animals in Narnia from animals in our world, so except from talking they have to share the same physiology as them. Plus, what's wrong with adding a little scientific info? It adds more to the page, and broadens the brain more. Gives people more to read about, and teaches them a bit more about our ape cousins. Storyseeker1 (talk) 03:01, August 20, 2012 (UTC)
 * No I think the scientific stuff should be removed; it rarely applies to Narnian facts. People come here to read about how stuff applies to Narnia, not the scientific facts. And after all, Narnian talking animals are known to have had different sizes and even shapes from their Earthly counterparts!
 * Okay, though I think some things should be left alone, though, since I imagine they're the same as Narnian Gorillas. I've altered it a little. The thing about Gorillas walking on knuckles is certainly true to Narnian apes, as that's what the Gorilla in LWW was doing. I've removed the part about ape sizes, since we don't know for certain that's what Narnian gorillas are, since Narnians tend to be larger than their earth counterparts, though from what I saw in the film they seemed the same.   Storyseeker1 (talk) 11:06, August 20, 2012 (UTC)