Talk:Narnian Empire

Um...
I would hesitate say that the astrocratic islands were Narnian possesions, and certainly the Dark Island is a no man's land. - Tawaki 03:14, 3 July 2008 (UTC)

The Greatest Empire?
Surely the lands and armies of Calormen were much greater? Poggin 00:45, 4 September 2008 (UTC)

I totally agreeHallian the Shipbuilder 00:22, 26 March 2009 (UTC)

Maybe Narnia had more territories than Calormen, but Calormen had a greater military than Narnia. ~Anonymous 18:52, February 13, 2010 (UTC)
 * Narnia was smaller than the least of Calormen's provinces. ArvanSwordwielderSig.png●ArvanSwordwielderSigTalk.png

Archenland?
I never heard that Archenland was a possession of Narnia. Also I've seen no evidence that Galma, Terebinthia, or the Seven Isles were ever Narnian. Galma is an independent Duchy and Terebinthia is specifically mentioned as a kingdom. And since when was Ettinsmoor a 'failed state'?Hallian the Shipbuilder 00:17, 26 March 2009 (UTC)

Well.. Im pretty sure also that Archenland was not a posession of Narnia, but an ally. Aslan refers to them as different Kingdoms for the descendants of Frank to rule over. Also King Lune treats Edmund as an equal when he addresses him in the Horse and His Boy, rather than a superior. I am with the above that there is nothing in the books to indicate Galma, Terebinthia and the Seven Isles are owned by Narnia. The various newly discovered islands in VOTD are debatably Narnian posessions by right of discovery, however some are clearly not (Coriakin is said by Narnia to rule the Dufflepuds, Ramandu's Island is called Ramandu's Island.. etc). As far as I understand it the Narnian Empire should only consist of Narnia, The Lone Islands and debatably Ettinsmoor, since it is at various stages militarily dominated by the kingdom of Narnia. Atredies

17:07, February 15, 2010 (UTC)
 * I think I agree, and Archenland was not a posession of Narnia. ArvanSwordwielderSig.png●ArvanSwordwielderSigTalk.png