Talk:The Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian (film)/@comment-2095727-20101227153558/@comment-3263766-20101227204055

Calling Prince Caspian the worst recently made fantasy film is ridiculous, especially considering the release of its sequel, the Voyage of the Dawn Treader. However, I will answer all of your points individually. 1. The film has a more mature tone than the book, certainly. 2. The book has some pacing issues in the final act. 3. I don't know about the humor throughout, but the soldier stopping in the middle of a battle to say "You are a mouse" was as ridiculous and inane as your opinion of the rest of the film. 4. The dual between Miraz and Peter followed the book closely and was appropriately violent (in the book, Peter beheads Glozelle and cuts off his legs in one stroke). 5. Certain moments mirrored scenes from Lord of the Rings, but you won't find a fantasy without some similarities. 6. Comparing any movie to Lord of the Rings is unfair, although the river god does invoke comparison. As far as looking fake, I'm not exactly sure what a "real" river god looks like.

May I suggest re-watching the film with a more open mind, and next time check your grammar before posting.